Bethea's Byte
POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? D5FRa
Welcome to Bethea's Byte. If you are a member, please sign in and participate. If you are not a member, please sign up and join the conversation. We'd love to hear from you.
Bethea's Byte
POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? D5FRa
Welcome to Bethea's Byte. If you are a member, please sign in and participate. If you are not a member, please sign up and join the conversation. We'd love to hear from you.
Bethea's Byte
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
WELCOME TO YOUR HOME FOR NEWS, OPINIONS, DEBATES & YOUR VOICE -- BETHEA'S BYTE
Welcome guests and members to the home for News, Opinions, Debates and Your Voice... Bethea's Byte. To all guests of this site, please feel free to look things over, but you are encouraged to register and take part in discussing all news reports posted here. You are also encouraged, as a member to post your own news stories. We would love to have discussions on your news reports as well. You are further encouraged to debate these stories as well, especially in the political areas. All I ask is that no matter what side you're on, keep the debates civil. If you are joining us from another forum, we ask you to affiliate with us. We are more than happy to check you out, join your site and participate with you as well. Once again, you are welcome here at Bethea's Byte. Join in the conversation. Spark a discussion. Have a passionate debate. Most importantly, Let your voice be heard! BYTE THIS!
Log in

I forgot my password

Notifications
    Who is online?
    In total there are 3 users online :: 1 Registered, 0 Hidden and 2 Guests :: 1 Bot

    The Last Outlaw

    [ View the whole list ]


    Most users ever online was 156 on Wed Jul 03, 2019 11:22 am
    Statistics
    We have 33 registered users
    The newest registered user is GamrNrd

    Our users have posted a total of 4221 messages in 1729 subjects
    Latest topics
    » What are your plans for the day
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Yesterday at 9:34 am by Naiwen

    » Here's How Long Derek Chauvin Could Spend in Prison
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Tue Apr 20, 2021 8:37 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Derek Chauvin Convicted of Murder and Manslaughter in George Floyd's Death
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Tue Apr 20, 2021 5:55 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » 'Wheel of Fortune' Fans Call For Rule Change After Contestant Loses on Minor Technicality
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Thu Apr 08, 2021 3:12 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Fla. Teacher Who Presented Herself as 'Mother Figure' Accused of Sexually Abusing Student for Years
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Fri Apr 02, 2021 4:15 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Derek Chauvin Trial: MMA Fighter Who Watched George Floyd's Death Says He Called Police on the Police
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Tue Mar 30, 2021 10:36 am by The Last Outlaw

    » Gun Laws and Stats
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Mon Mar 29, 2021 4:11 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Floyd Family Kneels Outside Courthouse in Symbolic Statement
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Mon Mar 29, 2021 8:58 am by The Last Outlaw

    » Boulder Shooting: Multiple Injuries, Residents Take Shelter as Police Look For Gunman
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Tue Mar 23, 2021 11:28 am by The Last Outlaw

    » Person of Interest in the Deaths of 5 People, Including Ex-Wife, Allegedly Admits to Murdering 16
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Mon Mar 22, 2021 7:53 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » If You Haven’t Received Your 3rd Stimulus Check Yet, Here’s Why Wednesday Matters
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Mon Mar 22, 2021 6:17 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Free Byte: What Grinds My Gears? Cancel Culture
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Sun Mar 21, 2021 5:42 pm by Kyng

    » Tennessee Sister and Brother Charged with First-Degree Murder in the Death of Their Disabled Mother
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Sun Mar 21, 2021 5:37 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Spa Shooting Victims ID'd As Biden, Harris Head To Atlanta
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Fri Mar 19, 2021 12:18 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Food and more!
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Wed Mar 17, 2021 10:49 am by Naiwen

    » Michelle Obama Responds to Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's Oprah Winfrey Interview
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Tue Mar 16, 2021 10:11 am by The Last Outlaw

    » Queen Elizabeth Says Saddened by Harry and Meghan's Experiences
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Sun Mar 14, 2021 3:53 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Suicide Prevention
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Sat Mar 13, 2021 11:09 pm by The Last Outlaw

    » Jury Selection in Derek Chauvin Case Starts Despite Prosecutors Wanting to Halt Trial
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Tue Mar 09, 2021 9:35 am by The Last Outlaw

    » House Progressives Back Revised COVID-19 Aid Bill as Vote Nears
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Clock-10Mon Mar 08, 2021 3:49 pm by The Last Outlaw

    May 2021
    SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
          1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    3031     

    Calendar Calendar

    CBOX
    Affiliate With Bethea’s Byte


    Bethea's Byte

    Anti-Spam Bots!

    Submit Your Site To The Web's Top 50 Search Engines for Free!






    The Coffee House


    Planet Nexus





    IconSkouliki

    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case?

    View previous topic View next topic Go down

    Which Do You SIde With?

    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Poll_c100%POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Poll_c10 0% 
    [ 0 ]
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Poll_c100%POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Poll_c10 0% 
    [ 0 ]
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Poll_c100%POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Poll_c10 0% 
    [ 0 ]
     
    Total Votes : 0
     
    The Last Outlaw
    The Last Outlaw
    Male Posts : 1739
    Age : 45
    Join date : 2018-05-25
    Location : Salem, Oregon
    Status :
    Online
    Offline

    http://betheasbyte.com/forum

    PostThe Last Outlaw Sat Apr 13, 2019 7:11 am

    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? IUbQr

    Welcome to a brand-new edition of POINT -- COUNTERPOINT.  Who is Julian Assange and what is he really all about?  On the point, CNN says that Assange is an activist and not a journalist because of his "work" with Wikileaks.  Alan Dershowitz is asking the question is this another Pentagon Papers case?  Let's dive in and see where these opinions lead.  Here we go.

    NOTE: The opinions in these articles are the authors, as published by the source, and do not necessarily represent the views of Bethea's Byte.



    POINT

    From CNN

    Frida Ghitis wrote:
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? BBVQUup

    The images were shocking but not unexpected – a bedraggled Julian Assange removed from the Ecuadorean embassy in London Thursday by British police after nearly seven years of confinement. The Wikileaks founder had finally reached the end of his long and contentious asylum. And his much-delayed encounter with justice has arrived.

    Assange, Wikileaks and their supporters maintain that Britain, by arresting Assange on a US extradition warrant, is an accomplice to an assault against press freedom, arguing that their work, obtaining and releasing massive amounts of secret data, is not a crime.

    But Assange's claim that he is a journalist is false, as he has proven time and again. That he is not a journalist, however, will not preclude authoritarian governments from using his case to thwart the legitimate media.

    Assange should face justice, but the process will be a perilous one for the free press. If handled correctly by the courts, it should result in the development of a functioning definition of what a journalist is, depriving propaganda outlets and government agents of using the label to take cover – and providing the press with the protection it needs to inquire, investigate and report.

    Assange entered Ecuador's embassy in 2012, fleeing potential extradition to Sweden, where he faced sexual assault charges. Sweden dropped the case on a technicality, but prosecutors say they may reopen that case.

    https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/11/opinions/julian-assange-activist-not-journalist-ghitis/index.html
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/julian-assange-is-an-activist-not-a-journalist/ar-BBVQW3O




    COUNTERPOINT

    From The Week Magazine

    Alan Dershowitz wrote:
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? BBSY4tQ

    Before WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange gained asylum in the Ecuadorian embassy in London in 2012, he and his British legal team asked me to fly to London to provide legal advice about United States law relating to espionage and press freedom. I cannot disclose what advice I gave them, but I can say that I believed then, and still believe now, that there is no constitutional difference between WikiLeaks and the New York Times.

    If the New York Times, in 1971, could lawfully publish the Pentagon Papers, knowing that it included classified documents stolen by Rand Corporation military analyst Daniel Ellsberg from our government, then WikiLeaks was entitled, under the First Amendment, to publish classified material that Assange knew was stolen by former Army intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning from our government.

    So if prosecutors were to charge Assange with espionage or any other crime for merely publishing the Manning material, this would be another Pentagon Papers case with the same likely outcome. Many people misunderstand the actual Supreme Court ruling in the 1971 case. It did not say that the newspapers that were planning to publish the Pentagon Papers could not be prosecuted if they published classified material. It only said they could not be restrained – that is, stopped in advance – from publishing them. They did publish, and they were not prosecuted.

    The same result would probably follow if Assange were prosecuted for publishing classified material on WikiLeaks, though there is no guarantee that prosecutors might not try to distinguish the two cases on the grounds that the New York Times is a more responsible media outlet than WikiLeaks. But the First Amendment does not recognize degrees of responsibility. Indeed, when the First Amendment was written, our nation was plagued with irresponsible scandal sheets and broadsides. No one ever described political pamphleteers Thomas Paine or James Callender as responsible journalists.

    It is likely, therefore, that a prosecution of Assange for merely publishing classified material would fail. Moreover, Great Britain might be unwilling to extradite Assange for such a "political" crime. That is why prosecutors have chosen to charge him with a different crime: conspiracy to help Manning break into a government computer to steal classified material. Such a crime, if proven beyond a reasonable doubt, would have a far weaker claim to constitutional protection. The courts have ruled that journalists may not break the law in an effort to obtain material whose disclosure would be protected by the First Amendment.

    https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/438578-alan-dershowitz-is-julian-assange-another-pentagon-papers-case
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/alan-dershowitz-is-julian-assange-another-pentagon-papers-case/ar-BBVSAgs
    Now the opinions are left to you.  Which way do you see this.  Do you side with the Point or Counterpoint.  Vote and drop in your commentary.  I look forward to reading and responding to you.

    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? I6goy

    _________________
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? FBCTRPOINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? D5SsG
    POINT: Julian Assange Is An Activist, Not A Journalist  COUNTERPOINT: Is Julian Assange Another Pentagon Papers Case? Nexads420

    View previous topic View next topic Back to top

    Create an account or log in to leave a reply

    You need to be a member in order to leave a reply.

    Create an account

    Join our community by creating a new account. It's easy!


    Create a new account

    Log in

    Already have an account? No problem, log in here.


    Log in

     
    Permissions in this forum:
    You cannot reply to topics in this forum