To all guests of this site, please feel free to look things over, but you are encouraged to register and take part in discussing all news reports posted here. 
You are also encouraged, as a member to post your own news stories. Log in
Control Panel
|
|
|
|
Your profile 
Social
Private messages
OtherNotifications
Who is online?
In total there are 6 users online :: 1 Registered, 0 Hidden and 5 Guests
The Last Outlaw
Most users ever online was 156 on Wed Jul 03, 2019 11:22 am
The Last Outlaw
Most users ever online was 156 on Wed Jul 03, 2019 11:22 am
Statistics
We have 27 registered users
The newest registered user is Qwerty
Our users have posted a total of 3350 messages in 1401 subjects
The newest registered user is Qwerty
Our users have posted a total of 3350 messages in 1401 subjects
Top posters
Most active topic starters
Top posting users this week
Top posting users this month
Latest topics
Affiliate With Bethea’s Byte
Attorneys For Michelle Carter Ask US Supreme Court To Review Her Conviction In Suicide Case
Page 1 of 1 • Share
- The Last Outlaw
Head Administrator
-
Posts : 1346
Age : 44
Join date : 2018-05-25
Location : Salem, Oregon, USA
Status :
-
The Last Outlaw on Mon Jul 08, 2019 7:35 pm
From The Boston Globe
I wonder how THIS will play out in the Supreme Court. This girl is convicted of murder basically without laying a finger on her victim. If SCOTUS says otherwise, they may have to rethink the entire justice system as far as the crime and punishment for murder is concerned.
Just Saying.
Danny McDonald of The Boston Globe wrote:
Lawyers for Michelle Carter, who was convicted of involuntary manslaughter in 2017 for pressuring a troubled Massachusetts teenager through texts and phone calls into killing himself, are petitioning the US Supreme Court to review the case.
The lawyers filed the motion with the Supreme Court on Monday, seeking a review on First and Fifth Amendment grounds. Her communications with Conrad Roy III, the teenager who took his own life, “did not constitute speech that was ‘an integral part of conduct in violation of a valid criminal statute,’ ” the court filing stated.
The motion also questioned whether Carter’s conviction violated the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment “because in assisted or encouraged suicide cases, the common law of involuntary manslaughter fails to provide reasonably clear guidelines to prevent ‘arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement.’ ”
In a statement, Carter’s lawyers said her conviction should not stand. She did not cause Roy’s “tragic death and should not be held criminally responsible for his suicide,” said Daniel Marx, an attorney who represents Carter.
“This petition focuses on just two of the many flaws in the case against her that raise important federal constitutional issues for the US Supreme Court to decide,” he said. “First, charging Ms. Carter based on her words alone violated the First Amendment and the decision upholding her conviction created a conflict among state supreme courts. Second, her conviction violated due process because the vague common law of involuntary manslaughter fails to provide guidance to prevent arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement in morally fraught cases involving suicide.”
Carter was 17 when she urged Roy, a Mattapoisett resident, to kill himself in July 2014 — even after he told her he was too scared to go through with it. After a bench trial that drew national headlines, Judge Lawrence Moniz in June 2017 found Carter, of Plainville, guilty of involuntary manslaughter.
https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2019/07/08/attorneys-for-michelle-carter-ask-supreme-court-review-her-conviction-suicide-case/WIywPpcJCjAr7rNzl31DkP/story.html
I wonder how THIS will play out in the Supreme Court. This girl is convicted of murder basically without laying a finger on her victim. If SCOTUS says otherwise, they may have to rethink the entire justice system as far as the crime and punishment for murder is concerned.
Just Saying.
_________________
Create an account or log in to leave a reply
You need to be a member in order to leave a reply.
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
» What are your plans for the day.
» Last thing you ate/drank
» How are you feeling right now?
» UK offers citizenship to Hong Kong residents
» How Lincoln Project Anti-Trump Republicans Got Into His Head. Spoiler Alert: It Was Easy.
» Tiffany Haddish Spoofs Kanye West's Presidential Bid, Jokes She and Dave Chappelle Are Running
» You Want a Confederate Monument? My Body Is a Confederate Monument
» Why Do Trump, Allies Repost Racist Messaging and Will it Help His Re-Election Effort?
» The 8 Can’t-Miss Moments From ‘Macy’s 4th of July Fireworks Spectacular’
» Trump’s ‘Sleepy Joe’ Jibe at Biden is Falling Flat, Data Shows
» Tou Thao, Ex-Officer Charged in The Death of George Floyd, Released From Jail
» Hot Dog Champs Repeat as July 4 Gluttony Fest Moves Indoors
» Trump Pushes Racial Division, Flouts Virus Rules at Rushmore
» Trump Uses Mount Rushmore Speech to Deliver Divisive Culture War Message
» Meet the Supporters Trump Has Lost
» Trump: Black Lives Matter Mural in NYC a 'Symbol of Hate' That Would Denigrate Fifth Avenue
» Lori Daybell Hit with New Charges Weeks After Her Kids Were Found Dead on Husband’s Property
» Ex-Minneapolis Officers Charged in George Floyd’s Killing Get Tentative Trial Date in March
» Trump Says Push For Less Coronavirus Testing Was Sarcasm
» Coronavirus Testing: Anthony Fauci Says Task Force 'Seriously Considering' New Strategy
» New Zealand Edges Back to Normal After Quashing Coronavirus in 49 Days
» A Friendly (Annual) Reminder
» TV Stars Who Got Their Starts on Daytime Soaps
» A Second Stimulus Check? Here's How Much You Could Get
» Minneapolis Police Officers Pen Open Letter Condemning Former Officer Derek Chauvin
» Kelly Clarkson Files For Divorce From Brandon Blackstock After Nearly Seven Years of Marriage
» Marches Aren't Enough. New York Protest Leaders Have Lasting Change in Mind.
» Momentum Builds to End Qualified Immunity For Police Officers in the Wake of George Floyd's Killing
» Human Remains Found at Property of Man Tied to Missing Kids
» George Floyd Funeral: Joe Biden and Rev. Al Sharpton Deliver Remarks
» What are you looking forward to right now?
» A Sheriff Put Down His Baton to Listen to Protesters. They Chanted 'Walk With Us,' So He Did
» As Trump Rekindles NFL Fight, Goodell Sides With Players
» Gayle King Says She's Fearful for Her Son as a Black Man In America
» Trump Tweets a Letter Calling Protesters ‘Terrorists’
» 3 More Minneapolis Officers Charged in George Floyd Death, Derek Chauvin Charges Elevated
» Race, Justice, George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, The Protests, The Riots, The Looting...
» Gregg Popovich Unleashes Fiery Statement on Trump: 'What We Have is a Fool in Place of a President'
» If We Had a Real Leader
» Chris Wallace Debunks Trump: No Record of Massive or Serious Fraud From Mail-In Voting
» Trump is Getting Trounced Among a Crucial Constituency: The Haters
» White woman went to 'racist place' calling cops on black man in Central Park, but she doesn't deserve death threats, he says
» Jamie Foxx Defends Jimmy Fallon Amid SNL Blackface Backlash
» Trump Threatens to Close Social Media After Being Fact Checked on Twitter (2 Articles)
» Can We Stop Pretending Trump Is Fit To Be President?
» Court Says Governor’s Church-Closing Rule Stands
» Trump Hits Biden and Obama in Defense of His Golfing
» Trump’s ‘Rigged Election’ Talk Sparks Fear of Post-Election Chaos
» U.S. Coronavirus Death Toll Nears 100,000
» Trump Says US Won't Close Over Second COVID-19 Wave
» 20 Hit Songs You Won't Believe Are Turning 20 This Year
» Judge Napolitano: Trump Doesn't Have Right to Override Governors on Church Openings
» Next U.S. Coronavirus Rescue Package Not Too Far Off, McConnell Says
» Duane Chapman Honors Late Wife on Anniversary
» 'Obamagate' Backfires: Documents Show Biden, Obama Acted Properly
» Forum Games Cafe!
» Ex-WWE Star Shad Gaspard Found Dead After Going Missing While Swimming
» Trump Is Now Doing to Himself What He’s Done to the Country
» He Thought the Coronavirus Was 'A Fake Crisis.' Then He Contracted It.
» My Youtube Vlog!
» Ahmaud Arbery Shooting: Man Who Took Video of Killing Faces Calls for Arrest
» Judge Tosses Out Oregon's Coronavirus Restrictions
» This is Why Trump is Back To Attacking Obama
» Churchgoer Potentially Exposed 180 Others to COVID-19
» McConnell: Obama 'Should Have Kept His Mouth Shut' on Trump's Coronavirus Response
» House Clears Way For Passage of $3 Trillion Coronavirus-Relief Bill
» McConnell Says He Was ‘Wrong’ to Claim That Obama Administration Left No Pandemic Plan
» Democrats Accuse Republicans of 'Bad Faith' As They Invoke National Debt to Pause Pandemic Aid
» Family Seeks Answers in Fatal Police Shooting of Louisville Woman in Her Apartment
» House Democrats Unveil New $3 Trillion Relief Bill With Aid to States, Direct Payments to Americans
» WWE Superstar Becky Lynch Expecting First Child with Fiancé Seth Rollins: 'We're So Excited'
» Georgia AG Calls For Federal Investigation Into Handling of Ahmaud Arbery case: What We Know
» Kim Jong Un’s Sister Is in the Spotlight. But Could a Woman Ever Lead North Korea?
» Arrests Made in Shooting Death of Black Man After Outcry
» Trump Administration Asks Supreme Court to Stop Release of Mueller Material
» AP Exclusive: US Shelves Detailed Guide to Reopening Country
» Trump Says Coronavirus Task Force Will Keep Working 'Indefinitely,' With a Focus on Vaccines and Reopening
» Nikki Bella Was Raped Twice in High School
» Trump Responds to Project Lincoln Ad by Conservatives Who Want Him Out of Office: 'They're All LOSERS'
» U.S. Coronavirus Deaths Exceed 70,000 as Forecasting Models Predict Grim Summer
» Duane 'Dog the Bounty Hunter' Chapman is Engaged 10 Months After Wife Beth's Death
» Bush Calls for Unity. Trump Attacks Bush. And Then a Host of Others.
» Report: China Hid Coronavirus' Severity to Hoard Supplies
» When Will US Reach 100,000 Deaths? After a Horrific April, Grim Milestone Could Hit in May
» Biden Denies Tara Reade’s Assault Allegation: ‘This Never Happened’
» 'Space Jam' Sequel Finally Has a Title (and It's Not 'Space Jam 2')
» Inspirational Quotes.
» Garth Brooks and Wife Trisha Yearwood to Perform at Legendary Grand Ole Opry Saturday Night Broadcast
» Trump vs FOX News: Why the President is Furious at the Conservative Network